Monday, December 6, 2010

"We are the best hotel company in the world"

The following is an excerpt from a job interview I had today at one of most prestigious five star hotels in Munich (a hint: their logo includes the name of a delicious fruit)

After several questions from the Front Desk Manager:

FDM: Do you have any questions?
Me: Why are you still working here (I was trying to get at what makes this a good work environment)?
FDM: Well, I’m here to do the interview, not you..... (awkward silence for a couple seconds). Well, we want to be the best hotel, the best hotel company in the world. Everybody that works here shares that commitment. The work here is exhausting, with long work hours. But when we leave these doors, we all know that we have worked at the best hotel.
Me: How do you define the best?
FDM: Well, we want to be the best in quality, the best in customer satisfaction, the best in room rates. Do you even know what is our average room rate?
Me: I know that the Best Available Rate (rate that’s sold online) starts at 400 Euros per night and I was just told that it can go up to 3500 Euros per night. So I’m guessing, or I hope it would be around 500 or at least 450 Euros.
FDM: (silence) (I’m assuming he didn’t think I would have any clue about the rates)

I’m printing this excerpt because I had to think (and laugh) about it for many hours afterwards. Another funny thing was that in the middle of the interview he asked me if we can continue the conversation in English. (I’ve lived in the states for over 6 years, so I guess I can speak English). What was funny was that it wasn’t hard to tell that he spoke English with a think German accent (Germans would say Gjarman Aktzent).

But he was brave and continued the conversation in English until the end. But I want to come back to the conversation about “wanting to become the best hotel in the city/ world”. How often have you heard or read that “we want to become the best hotel in the world?” I hear or read about it at least once a month. Everybody wants to become the best! And if you then ask, so what does it actually mean to be the best? Most people then say things like, well, being the best in everything (room rate, guest satisfaction, etc.). But this is so standard, no hint of authenticity and real strategy. I even think that this is not attainable if that is the goal. So why would we set ourself such a lofty goal? Well, I think it comes from the selfish idea of “I want to be the best, I want to be above others.” And that’s the motivation for what Germans call the “Ellenbogengesellschaft” (Elbow-Society). It’s our desire to be better than the rest and we do this by suppressing our neighbors (with our elbows)

Yet, I am completely against this view. As I mentioned before, I don’t know any hotel (or any company for that fact) that has been successful for a long period with that credo. Enron was extremely successful with this credo, but only until the world really knew that there was no substance, no real profit behind the doors. So back to Hotels. I believe that any hotel which proclaims to be the best, and when asked what it means to be the best, has no real idea why it is the best, is for sure not the best!

I don’t want to look down on this hotel just because one of the managers doesn't give a satisfying answer to what makes this hotel great. On the brighter side, the the human resource manager was very friendly, personal, and thoughtful. So that give me hope that this hotel is better than the one I am working at the moment (more to that later).